O'Malley Tunstall PLLC
Call 24-hours a day Free consultation No Fees Unless we Win
800-755-1987
Offices in Raleigh, North Carolina, and Eastern North Carolina

Susan O'Malley's Social Security Decision Ten year Anniversary

Susan O'Malley's Social Security Decision Ten year Anniversary

TEN YEAR ANNIVERSARY OF HINES V. BARNHART


In 2006 our office successfully defended the decision to approve Social Secuirty Disability benefits for our client by a Federal District Court Judge. 453 F.3d 559 (4th Cir. 2006).  

Our client suffered from sickle cell disease. This disease can cause many different problems such as joint pain, fatigue and even damage organs in some cases. The Administrative Law Judge denied Mr. Hines benefits finding that since he had no organ damage from his sickle cell disease it could not be as severe as he claimed. That finding was not consistent with the law, so out office appealed the denial from Social Security. The District Court Judge and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that the law allows an individual to prove the severity of their medical condition through testimony once the medical condition has been established by appropriate diagnosis. The decision also held that the hypothetical questions to a vocational expert in a hearing had to contain all of the relevant limitations supported by the record in order to sustain a denial. 


Susan O'Malley argued before a panel of judges at the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. The judges, through their written decision, in Hines v. Barnhart confirmed a standing Federal Court case that subjective evidence (testimony of the claimant and witnesses) could be used to support a finding of disability based on the pain and limitations that a medical condition causes. We and other attorneys continue to use the law confirmed in Hines v. Barnhart to help our clients in appealing denied cases.

We find that quite often once a doctor has made a diagnosis they do not need to ask about all of the limitations it causes because they are only concerned with the treatment or maintenance of a condition.   The doctor understands what the patient is telling him. However, when the words fine or okay appear in a medical record the Judge may assume that means you are having no problems from your conditions. This makes it important to always tell your doctor what your limitations are so that the medical records are consistent with your testimony.


We are proud of Susan and that our office has been able to help not only our client but also those who came after by confirming the case law that testimony is a means of proving disability that is caused by pain.  What a great time of the year to discuss the true benefit of Susan O'Malley's Social Security Decision Ten year Anniversary!

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Contextual Contextaul Contextaul
Contextaul Contextaul Contextaul
Contextaul Contextaul Contextaul
Contextaul Contextaul Contextaul
Contextaul Contextaul Contextaul
Contextaul Contextaul Contextaul
Contextaul Contextaul Contextaul

Free Initial Consultations. No Attorney Fees Unless We Win.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Lead Counsel Rated | LC
Call 24-hours a day We’ll Come To You No Attorney Fees Unless we Win
Review Us

Raleigh Office
8300 Falls of Neuse Road, Suite 108
Raleigh, NC 27615

Toll Free: 800-755-1987
Phone: 919-277-0150
Fax: 252-641-9009
Raleigh Law Office Map

Tarboro Office
405 North Main Street
Tarboro, NC 27886

Toll Free: 800-755-1987
Phone: 252-823-2266
Fax: 252-641-9009
Tarboro Law Office Map